How we rate casinos

Every casino on StakesCheck is rated with the same four components and the same weights. This page sets out what each component measures, how the four become one rating, and how that rating decides where a casino ranks.

The four components

Each one is scored from 0 to 10. The bars are drawn to scale.

  1. 40%

    Trust

    Licensing, operator transparency, enforcement history, and the shape of the review distribution read against the sector baseline. The heaviest weight, because it is the one thing you cannot check for yourself before you deposit.

  2. 25%

    Payout speed

    Published processing times, redemption minimums, and what players report. Social casinos pay no prizes, so they score a neutral 5 here rather than being marked down for their own model, and the review says so.

  3. 20%

    Games

    Library depth, provider quality, and whether the categories on offer are real. A game count the operator cannot state consistently pulls this down: it does not get credit for the larger number.

  4. 15%

    Bonus honesty

    Are the terms findable, is the playthrough reasonable, and can a normal player reach the advertised offer. A large bonus that no free player can reach scores worse than a small one they can.

From four scores to one rating

The four component scores are weighted, trust 40%, payout speed 25%, games 20% and bonus honesty 15%, and combined into one rating out of five, shown to one decimal place.

The scale is deliberately harsh. Five out of five would need a perfect score on all four components at once, and nothing in this market earns that. Read a 4.5 here as a strong result rather than a qualified one.

Ties and uneven gaps are expected. Two operators with similar evidence should get the same rating, and a site with no named operator belongs visibly below one that publishes its company details, not a tenth of a point below it. Where a claim cannot be confirmed, it is scored as though it were not true.

Today 112 casinos carry a rating, and 78 of them have all four component scores. The rest show their overall rating, and the components that have not been scored yet are marked as missing rather than guessed.

How trust is scored

Trust carries the most weight, so its scale is spelled out. These are the anchor points; a casino can land between them.

ScoreWhat it means
10State-licensed by a US gaming regulator, audited games, an enforceable dispute path
8Named operator, long payout history, strong review distribution, no enforcement actions
6Named operator, decent reputation, ordinary offshore or sweepstakes footing
4Thin corporate disclosure, a meaningful complaint pattern, or recent enforcement
2No named operating entity, or active litigation alongside a poor review distribution
0Evidence of non-payment

Three rules that matter more than the average star score

  • Review distributions are read against the sector. Almost every gambling operator, licensed or offshore, sits between 85 and 93 percent one-star reviews on the public review platforms. Sitting inside that band tells us nothing and costs an operator nothing. Only a distribution clearly worse than the band, or a complaint pattern that names non-payment, moves the score down.
  • Enforcement is weighed by what it did to players' money. A penalty over self-exclusion failures, identity checks, withheld withdrawals or misleading bonus terms counts heavily. One over a sports market, an advert or licensing paperwork counts for little or nothing.
  • Volume matters. Three hundred reviews is a soft signal. Twenty thousand is a strong one.

How rankings are ordered

Ranking pages sort by rating, highest first. Because the rating has one decimal place, ties are common, and two casinos on the same rating are rarely equal underneath it. A tie breaks on the trust score first, then on payout speed, and only then on the name. A casino without a component breakdown cannot win a tie-break: it sorts to the bottom of its rating rather than letting a missing number decide its position.

Who can be ranked at all

Scoring a casino and recommending it are separate questions.

  • Operators that exclude US residents. If an operator's own terms shut out US players, it is left out of every ranking and every top pick, and there is no sign-up link to it. Its review stays up and says so at the top, because someone searching the brand deserves a straight answer.
  • Operators under state stop-orders. They keep their place in a ranking, with the reason printed on their card, but never hold a homepage top pick.
  • Closed or unverified sites. A casino that has shut down, or one we could not verify, is out of the rankings entirely.

Disagree with a score?

The rubric is published so you can argue with it. Read more about StakesCheck, browse the rankings, or tell us what we got wrong. Corrections are welcome and we publish them.

Play responsibly. Stay in control.

Must be 18+ (21+ in some states). If gambling stops being fun, get help from the National Council on Problem Gambling or call 1-800-GAMBLER.